Even the most talented performers may find it challenging and enormous to play the monumental role of Jesus Christ on film. As time has passed, many audiences have grown weary of the typical blond and blue-eyed depictions of a Christ who would have surely been brown-skinned and Middle Eastern. Throughout the decades, many of Hollywood’s brightest stars have attempted to bring the historical figure to life, often to polarising results. The best actors have been able to establish a long legacy and win critical praise for their depictions in both television and film, despite the fact that performances have evolved with time.
With Jim Caviezel playing the crucial role of Jesus in the divisive, R-rated epic The Passion of the Christ, director Mel Gibson created quite the impression. When the revered comedic genius Mel Brooks portrayed the holy figure in the renowned parody History of the World, Part I with the legendary John Hurt as Jesus of Nazareth, controversy also followed. Some of the best actors to portray Jesus Christ are included here.
Brian Deacon (Jesus)
The 1979 Biblical drama Jesus, starring Englishman Brian Deacon as the eponymous character, uses the Gospel of Luke to recount the life narrative of Jesus Christ. It is widely regarded as the most-watched movie of all time. Due to his “ethnically right” olive skin, the talented Shakespearean actor was chosen over over 900 other candidates for the important job.
Deacon read several Bible translations every day in order to accurately capture the teachings of Christ in order to provide an accurate and modest portrait of Jesus. The most translated movie in history, Jesus has apparently been seen eight billion times by more than four billion individuals, according to a 2020 study.
Jeffrey Hunter (King of Kings)
King of Kings, a 1961 epic drama directed by Nicholas Ray, portrays the life of Jesus Christ from birth to resurrection, events that are detailed in the New Testament. Producer Samuel Bronston chose Jeffrey Hunter above competitors including Alex Guinness, Peter Cushing, and Max von Sydow for the part partly because to the actor’s mesmerising eyes; he once said, “I was very drawn to him by his eyes. It was crucial that the actor portraying Christ have distinctive eyes.”
Hunter’s portrayal received praise and turned out to be one of his most cherished and remembered performances, despite the fact that the movie itself received mixed reviews from reviewers. Hunter once said, “There are some things that can’t be measured in dollars and cents, and how can anyone put a price—even the price of a million-dollar career—on the position of the greatest Being this mortal earth has ever known?
Jim Caviezel (The Passion of the Christ)
Icon Productions Mel Gibson’s 2004 epic drama The Passion of the Christ generated waves and polarised audiences, with some perceiving the film as a life-defining sacred experience and others deeming it antisemitic. The film chronicles Jesus’ final 12 hours as portrayed in the New Testament of the Bible. Despite Gibson’s own warnings that participation in the contentious epic could harm his career, Jim Caviezel was chosen to play Jesus; he reacted to the director by declaring, “Mel, I firmly believe this. We all need to bear a cross. I’m required to bear my own cross. We will be crushed by the weight of our crosses if we don’t carry them. So let’s get started.”
The Passion of the Christ received overwhelmingly positive reviews among the evangelical community, but receiving a mixed reception overall (as was predicted). It also obtained a renowned A+ CinemaScore rating. The Biblical drama received three Oscar nominations, and although though Caviezel’s portrayal of Jesus is one of the most talked-about in cinema, it continues to be one of the most divisive and violent movies ever made.
John Hurt (History of the World, Part I)
In typical Mel Brooks style, the iconic filmmaker gave Jesus the humorous treatment in the 1981 star-studded parody History of the World, Part I, enlisting John Hurt’s assistance to play the religious figure at the Last Supper.
Audiences laughed and particularly appreciated his participation in the movie’s “The Roman Empire” section, where Brooks’ character Comicus repeatedly interrupts Jesus as they discuss who would betray him and uses his name in vain in the famous scene before Leonardo da Vinci arrives to paint the men. Hulu revealed intentions to produce a television series sequel, with History of the World, Part II scheduled to launch in March, 40 years after the Part I broadcast.
Joseph Mawle (The Passion)
Joseph Mawle played the monumental responsibility of bringing Jesus Christ to life on television in the BBC’s 2008 miniseries The Passion, which followed the events leading up to his death. To exhibit Jesus as the more humanistic, accessible Christ shown in the Gospels of Mark and Matthew, rather than giving him the more deified image seen mainly in John, author Frank Deasy spent a year researching Jerusalem, the gospels in Israel, and the way of life typical in the first century.
Mawle read to be ready for his performance “The work was both terrifying and amazing in equal measure, he subsequently reflected on his time portraying Jesus, saying, “the Gospels, study papers, medical documents, innumerable books, and prayers.” Both pressure and pleasure were equal in intensity.”
Max von Sydow (The Greatest Story Ever Told)
Max von Sydow has had a legendary career spanning seventy years, and his portrayal of Jesus Christ in the 1965 epic The Greatest Story Ever Told is without a doubt one of his best. The excellent film, for which von Sydow studied at UCLA for six months in order to prepare for the part, served as his first English-language acting assignment and served to make him more well-known to viewers abroad.
When asked how he embodied the historical character and the tremendous strain that goes along with it, von Sydow said, “As a guy, I portrayed him. I portrayed Jesus as a man, not as the Son of God or a divine being.”
Robert Powell (Jesus of Nazareth)
Robert Powell’s stunning portrayal of the revered figure in the 1977 British-Italian TV miniseries Jesus of Nazareth dramatises the Savior’s life as it is described in the Gospel and is frequently recognised as one of the best representations of Jesus Christ to ever grace the screen. Dustin Hoffman and Al Pacino were both strongly considered for the role, but Powell ultimately won it. With his mesmerising blue eyes and authoritative demeanour, Powell gave a memorable and well regarded performance. Powell gave his everything to playing Jesus, starving himself for 12 days on nothing but cheese to film the crucifixion scene.
During the drama’s filming, Powell spoke about his thoughts on playing Christ: “I consider it a gift to perform this role and share the experience every day. It is hard to avoid being influenced by this story while living it. As a result of having to speak the words of this historical figure, I believe that I have already become much more modest. His persona and his beliefs have come to life in my mind.”
Ted Neeley (Jesus Christ Superstar)
The 1973 drama musical Jesus Christ Superstar, an adaption of the enormously successful Andrew Lloyd Webber rock opera musical of the same name, centres on the developing conflict between Jesus Christ and Judas and the events that led to his crucifixion and death. The amazing film, which Ted Neeley stars in and for which he has been nominated for a Golden Globe, uses songs like “Everything’s Alright” and “Superstar” to help tell its story. Ted Neeley gives an outstanding performance. Neeley had previously filled the role of Jesus in the Broadway production and would return to it frequently in subsequent productions.
Director Norman Jewison claims that he was able to show the movie to Pope Paul VI and that he “freely adored what he observed. Speaking to Mr. Jewison, he stated, “Mr. Jewison, not only do I enjoy your wonderful rock opera film, but I believe it will convert more people to Christianity than anything else ever has.””
Willem Dafoe (The Last Temptation of Christ)
For the 1988 epic religious drama The Last Temptation of Christ, which follows Jesus of Nazareth as he battles with comprehending his life’s path and fulfilling his divine destiny, brilliant performing chameleon Willem Dafoe teamed up with great filmmaker Martin Scorsese.
Due to its departure from how Jesus was shown in the Bible and a fictitious dream scene, the movie, like the novel it was based on, was controversial. Nevertheless, Dafoe’s performance was praised, with many people thinking it was Oscar-worthy. According to The Chicago Tribune, “Dafoe is able to engross us in the mystery, suffering, and happiness of the holy life. Not another one of those dull biblical costume epics, this one. In this film, there is a real challenge and optimism.”